RHS Not Being Updated in MultiScenario Problem
Awaiting user inputHi,
I am trying to make a multi scenario model where, for each scenario, we explore incrementing a single constraint. I have been using the sensitivity example for reference.
I have implemented a class, SensitivityAnalyzer, which is basically a wrapper around a base problem. I am implementing a class to make a user interface easier, farther down the road.
class SensitivityAnalyzer:
def __init__(
self,
base_problem : VBAProblem,
):
"""
Arguments
------------
base_problem : VBA_Problem
Base problem we'll build the scenarios from
increment : int
How much to increment each element we'll generate a scenario for.
sets : typing.Iterable[str]
Any of ('L','C','V','S') that indicate which set we want to generate scenarios over. We will increment each element of teh requested sets and generate a scenario for each incremented element
omissions : dict[str, set[str]]
A dict whose keys must be contained in sets. For the requested sets, do not generate a scenario for the element's in this args keys.
"""
self.Model=base_problem.Model
self.Model.num_scenarios = 0
def generate_scenarios(self, base_problem, increment, sets, omissions = None) :
scen_index = 0
for it in sets:
#elements to generate scenario which are the base set - the elements of the set
#that are present in omissions
els = base_problem.getSet(it)
#if they provided some omissions, remove them from this elements
if omissions :
els = els - omissions.get(it,set())
self.Model.num_scenarios += len(els)
self.Model.update()
for e in els:
# logging.debug(f'Generating scenario {scen_index+1} / {self.Model.NumScenarios}')
#make scenario where this element is incremented
self.generate_constraint_scenario(
scen_index,
f'{it}_supply_{e.ID}',
increment
)
#increment scenario number so next loop is new scenario
scen_index += 1
logging.info(f'{len(els)} scenarios generated for set {it}.')
def generate_constraint_scenario(self,scenNum , element_name, increment) :
#Initialize the scenario with the scenario number, give it a name
self.Model.Params.ScenarioNumber =scenNum
self.Model.ScenNName = element_name
#get the constraint we're gonna modify
constr = self.Model.getConstrByName(element_name)
assert constr is not None, f'Unable to retrieve constraint {element_name}'
#save the original value
og_rhs = constr.RHS
#increment it
new_rhs=og_rhs+increment
logging.debug(f'Setting {element_name} RHS to {new_rhs} from {og_rhs}')
#set constraint right hand side to new value
constr.ScenNRHS=new_rhs
The output when I am generating the scenarios looks good. I can see that new_rhs has the correct value in SensitivityAnalyzer::generate_constraint_scenario
sa = SensitivityAnalyzer(P)
sa.generate_scenarios(P, 500000, ['C'])
Outputs, as expected
DEBUG: Setting C_supply_301-0963|E RHS to 2890200.0 from 2390200.0
DEBUG: Setting C_supply_300-8792|E2 RHS to 2490200.0 from 1990200.0
DEBUG: Setting C_supply_301-0963|G RHS to 2699296.0 from 2199296.0
DEBUG: Setting C_supply_301-0963|K RHS to 2940200.0 from 2440200.0
DEBUG: Setting C_supply_300-8792|M RHS to 2940200.0 from 2440200.0
DEBUG: Setting C_supply_300-8792|N RHS to 2150200.0 from 1650200.0
DEBUG: Setting C_supply_300-8792|L RHS to 3040200.0 from 2540200.0
DEBUG: Setting C_supply_300-8792|B RHS to 5530000.0 from 5030000.0
INFO: 8 scenarios generated for set C.
But once I call
sa.Model.optimize()
and inspect the constraint RHS in each of the scenarios, they are still at their original values.
for i in range(sa.Model.num_scenarios):
sa.Model.Params.ScenarioNumber =i
print(sa.Model.ScenNName)
print('Base Problem RHS:', P.Model.getConstrByName(sa.Model.ScenNName).RHS)
print(f'Scenario {i} RHS: ', sa.Model.getConstrByName(sa.Model.ScenNName).RHS)
print(f'Scenario {i} Obj Val', sa.Model.ScenNObjVal)
Outputs
C_supply_301-0963|K
Base Problem RHS: 2440200.0
Scenario 0 RHS: 2440200.0
Scenario 0 Obj Val 8162244.5C_supply_300-8792|M
Base Problem RHS: 2440200.0
Scenario 1 RHS: 2440200.0
Scenario 1 Obj Val 8162244.5C_supply_300-8792|B
Base Problem RHS: 5030000.0
Scenario 2 RHS: 5030000.0
Scenario 2 Obj Val 8162244.5C_supply_301-0963|G
Base Problem RHS: 2199296.0
Scenario 3 RHS: 2199296.0
Scenario 3 Obj Val 8162244.5C_supply_300-8792|L
Base Problem RHS: 2540200.0
Scenario 4 RHS: 2540200.0
Scenario 4 Obj Val 8162244.5C_supply_301-0963|E
Base Problem RHS: 2390200.0
Scenario 5 RHS: 2390200.0
Scenario 5 Obj Val 8162244.5C_supply_300-8792|N
Base Problem RHS: 1650200.0
Scenario 6 RHS: 1650200.0
Scenario 6 Obj Val 8162244.5C_supply_300-8792|E2
Base Problem RHS: 1990200.0
Scenario 7 RHS: 1990200.0
Scenario 7 Obj Val 8162244.5
Not too sure what I'm overlooking here.
-
Official comment
This post is more than two years old. Some information may not be up to date. For current information, please check the Gurobi Documentation or Knowledge Base. If you need more help, please create a new post in the community forum, or try Gurobot, our chatbot interface offering instant, expert-level support. -
Hi,
You seem to be referring to the RHS attribute for each scenario.print(f'Scenario {i} RHS: ', sa.Model.getConstrByName(sa.Model.ScenNName).RHS)Does it work if you change it to ScenNRHS attribute?
print(f'Scenario {i} RHS: ', sa.Model.getConstrByName(sa.Model.ScenNName).ScenNRHS)Regards,
Ryuta0
Post is closed for comments.
Comments
2 comments