Vectorizing addition of constraints
I'm using the Python API. Is there a vectorized way to add the following constraints?
model.addConstrs((
v <= u[:, :, i] @ x
for i in range(u.shape[2])
))
where v and x are MVars, e.g.
v.shape == (2,)
x.shape == (3,)
u.shape == (2, 3, 4)
This is a timecritical component of my program, but Python for loops are very slow and take up a lot of time.

Unfortunately, no. However, the following may be more efficient for this model since it avoids some intermediate Python objects:
for i in range(u.shape[2]):
model.addMConstrs(u[:, :, i], x, '>', v)0 
Greg Glockner That yields the following error:
Traceback (most recent call last):
...
model.addMConstrs(u[:, :, i], x, '>', v)
File "model.pxi", line 3414, in gurobipy.Model.addMConstrs
TypeError: object of type 'MVar' has no len()0 
More generally, are there plans to add a completely vectorized interface like that of cvxopt.solvers.lp (ideally with the addition of a batch dimension)? This would be extremely useful.
Currently cvxopt.solvers.lp (with GLPK) is >6 times faster for me, simply due to model construction/specification overhead. (My program needs to solve a large batch of linear programs, which presently involves constructing and solving models repeatedly.)
0 
Hello Carlos,
I have taken note of your request for an API to solve many small models in bulk. In order to understand the overhead problem you are facing a little better, it would be very valuable if you could post a concise benchmark example here that demonstrates the enourmous overhead w.r.t. cvxpy.solvers.lp/GLPK.
Greg's suggestion from above won't work (as you saw...) because the RHS argument to addMConstrs must be a data vector, not an MVar object. You would need to normalize the constraint u[:,:.i] @ x >= v to the form A @ z >= 0 yourself in order to go through this function, but I'm afraid the benefit will be quite small.
Thanks,
Robert
0 
Robert Luce Here is an example: Solving batches of twoplayer zerosum normalform games. I get times like
gurobi 0.37076228499999986
cvxopt 0.009740684000000055
gurobi 0.39596498599999985
cvxopt 0.009115292999999802
gurobi 0.3703212579999997
cvxopt 0.007263605999999978when running on a 2.5 GHz QuadCore Intel Core i7 processor with 16 GB 1600 MHz DDR3 memory.
0 
I see there's a Feature Requests subforum, should I post this there?
I suppose the ideal interface might look something like
def max_min(batch):
model = gurobipy.Model()
v = model.addMVar(batch.shape[0])
x = model.addMVar((batch.shape[0], batch.shape[1]))
model.setObjective(v, gurobipy.GRB.MAXIMIZE) # note this is vectorized
model.addConstrs((
x.sum(1) == 1,
x >= 0,
v[:, None] <= (batch * x[:, :, None]).sum(1),
))
model.optimize()
return model.objValAlternatively, inputting batches of c, A, b, G, h matrices would work too.
0
Please sign in to leave a comment.
Comments
6 comments