Objective value does not equal X * obj
回答済みRecently I encountered that (in some of my models) the variable values seem to be incorrectly stored into my data. When I try the following
int i, error;
double total_obj_by_hand=0, total_obj_by_gurobi;
error = GRBgetdblattrarray(model, "X", 0, n_vars, var_values);
for (i = 0; i < n_vars; i++)
{
total_obj_by_hand += obj[i] * var_values[i];
}
error = GRBgetdblattr(model, "ObjVal", &total_obj_by_gurobi);
total_obj_by_hand equals 38913.512444 whereas total_obj_by_gurobi equals 14459.446702. The value calculated by gurobi is the correct value and it is also the same as in the logs:
Gurobi 11.0.3 (win64) logging started Wed Oct 30 22:30:55 2024
Set parameter LogToConsole to value 0
Set parameter Username
Set parameter Method to value 2
Set parameter ScaleFlag to value 0
Set parameter BarHomogeneous to value 1
Set parameter Crossover to value 0
Set parameter PreDual to value 1
Set parameter IISMethod to value 1
Set parameter LogFile to value "solver_output_sub_model_no_investment_year_2040_hours_168-335.log"
Set parameter PreDepRow to value 0
Set parameter PrePasses to value 1
Set parameter Presolve to value 1
Set parameter SolutionTarget to value 1
Set parameter Threads to value 20
Academic license - for non-commercial use only - expires 2025-07-28
Gurobi Optimizer version 11.0.3 build v11.0.3rc0 (win64 - Windows Server 2022.0 (20348.2))
CPU model: AMD EPYC 7763 64-Core Processor, instruction set [SSE2|AVX|AVX2]
Thread count: 128 physical cores, 256 logical processors, using up to 20 threads
Optimize a model with 583921 rows, 5818297 columns and 7681188 nonzeros
Model fingerprint: 0xa87f1fe8
Coefficient statistics:
Matrix range [3e-01, 3e+02]
Objective range [1e-04, 5e+00]
Bounds range [2e-04, 1e+04]
RHS range [1e-03, 5e+03]
Presolve time: 5.90s
Presolved: 4693737 rows, 4929427 columns, 10433877 nonzeros
Elapsed ordering time = 5s
Elapsed ordering time = 12s
Ordering time: 40.46s
Barrier statistics:
Dense cols : 2612
Free vars : 15120
AA' NZ : 1.036e+08
Factor NZ : 1.885e+08 (roughly 5.0 GB of memory)
Factor Ops : 9.104e+10 (roughly 1 second per iteration)
Threads : 20
Objective Residual
Iter Primal Dual Primal Dual Compl Time
0 -5.88606747e+07 8.13608041e+08 6.80e+00 2.45e+01 4.74e+03 63s
1 -2.78151617e+07 2.84502805e+08 1.24e-01 5.48e+01 2.51e+02 66s
2 -9.98303883e+06 3.03218792e+07 3.80e-03 6.87e+00 2.67e+01 70s
3 -2.76744772e+06 1.48926049e+06 1.43e-04 3.02e-01 1.44e+00 75s
4 -6.46189690e+05 2.05578055e+05 6.46e-05 5.82e-02 2.32e-01 80s
5 -2.89496376e+05 8.24808878e+04 8.92e-05 2.43e-02 9.11e-02 84s
6 -1.29259697e+05 4.29666842e+04 1.09e-04 1.16e-02 3.62e-02 87s
7 -5.82207565e+04 2.64891749e+04 6.22e-05 5.05e-03 1.43e-02 92s
8 -1.53701777e+04 1.86243513e+04 3.78e-05 1.05e-03 4.43e-03 97s
9 -3.05119085e+03 1.73603405e+04 3.90e-05 6.92e-04 2.52e-03 101s
10 3.88504674e+03 1.66818847e+04 4.89e-05 5.14e-04 1.53e-03 104s
11 6.84335416e+03 1.61699582e+04 4.04e-05 3.83e-04 1.08e-03 108s
12 9.26236707e+03 1.53876329e+04 6.47e-05 1.90e-04 6.72e-04 112s
13 1.05629909e+04 1.51217563e+04 5.14e-05 1.27e-04 4.90e-04 118s
14 1.14694206e+04 1.49443122e+04 4.01e-05 8.65e-05 3.68e-04 124s
15 1.22305095e+04 1.48424680e+04 3.04e-05 6.44e-05 2.75e-04 131s
16 1.26328017e+04 1.47541480e+04 2.52e-05 4.63e-05 2.21e-04 136s
17 1.30412164e+04 1.46799027e+04 2.71e-05 3.16e-05 1.70e-04 142s
18 1.32922358e+04 1.46524075e+04 2.31e-05 2.66e-05 1.41e-04 148s
19 1.35107442e+04 1.46157187e+04 1.85e-05 2.02e-05 1.14e-04 155s
20 1.36757239e+04 1.45924749e+04 1.70e-05 1.64e-05 9.45e-05 161s
21 1.37928950e+04 1.45672678e+04 1.84e-05 1.24e-05 7.97e-05 167s
22 1.39266370e+04 1.45536142e+04 2.01e-05 1.03e-05 6.44e-05 172s
23 1.40640736e+04 1.45394539e+04 1.55e-05 8.34e-06 4.88e-05 178s
24 1.41564317e+04 1.45296884e+04 1.69e-05 7.07e-06 3.83e-05 185s
25 1.42112128e+04 1.45206053e+04 1.77e-05 5.94e-06 3.17e-05 190s
26 1.42502894e+04 1.45059667e+04 1.51e-05 4.26e-06 2.62e-05 197s
27 1.42836994e+04 1.44974210e+04 1.34e-05 3.32e-06 2.19e-05 203s
28 1.43106236e+04 1.44916794e+04 1.31e-05 2.71e-06 1.85e-05 210s
29 1.43229037e+04 1.44870985e+04 1.55e-05 2.25e-06 1.68e-05 216s
30 1.43536970e+04 1.44838869e+04 2.20e-05 1.93e-06 1.33e-05 223s
31 1.43625473e+04 1.44806663e+04 2.02e-05 1.63e-06 1.21e-05 230s
32 1.43746661e+04 1.44782098e+04 2.14e-05 1.40e-06 1.06e-05 237s
33 1.43874006e+04 1.44761145e+04 3.04e-05 1.22e-06 9.08e-06 244s
34 1.44096536e+04 1.44735288e+04 2.16e-05 9.93e-07 6.54e-06 251s
35 1.44189796e+04 1.44722073e+04 1.77e-05 8.86e-07 5.45e-06 258s
36 1.44264673e+04 1.44704791e+04 1.52e-05 7.52e-07 4.50e-06 264s
37 1.44330811e+04 1.44693868e+04 1.26e-05 6.71e-07 3.72e-06 271s
38 1.44346819e+04 1.44675690e+04 1.18e-05 5.39e-07 3.37e-06 279s
39 1.44387219e+04 1.44671483e+04 9.95e-06 5.08e-07 2.91e-06 285s
40 1.44416664e+04 1.44662623e+04 8.57e-06 4.45e-07 2.52e-06 293s
41 1.44438342e+04 1.44657001e+04 7.86e-06 4.06e-07 2.24e-06 300s
42 1.44461559e+04 1.44651909e+04 6.74e-06 3.70e-07 1.95e-06 307s
43 1.44480103e+04 1.44645619e+04 5.82e-06 3.26e-07 1.69e-06 315s
44 1.44497077e+04 1.44640106e+04 4.97e-06 2.89e-07 1.46e-06 322s
45 1.44515599e+04 1.44637214e+04 4.43e-06 2.69e-07 1.25e-06 330s
46 1.44523108e+04 1.44631360e+04 3.99e-06 2.30e-07 1.11e-06 337s
47 1.44531871e+04 1.44625270e+04 3.52e-06 1.90e-07 9.56e-07 345s
48 1.44538067e+04 1.44622639e+04 3.22e-06 1.72e-07 8.66e-07 352s
49 1.44548487e+04 1.44619445e+04 3.43e-06 1.51e-07 7.27e-07 361s
50 1.44555323e+04 1.44615529e+04 2.97e-06 1.25e-07 6.16e-07 369s
51 1.44560923e+04 1.44612643e+04 2.40e-06 1.07e-07 5.30e-07 377s
52 1.44564826e+04 1.44611187e+04 3.47e-06 9.73e-08 4.75e-07 386s
53 1.44568788e+04 1.44610285e+04 3.03e-06 9.15e-08 4.25e-07 395s
54 1.44569764e+04 1.44609030e+04 9.63e-06 8.35e-08 4.02e-07 404s
55 1.44574561e+04 1.44607709e+04 7.82e-06 7.52e-08 3.39e-07 414s
56 1.44576482e+04 1.44607494e+04 7.10e-06 7.38e-08 3.18e-07 422s
57 1.44577982e+04 1.44606481e+04 6.57e-06 6.75e-08 2.92e-07 433s
58 1.44579318e+04 1.44605783e+04 6.06e-06 6.32e-08 2.71e-07 443s
59 1.44580596e+04 1.44605208e+04 5.58e-06 5.96e-08 2.52e-07 453s
60 1.44581684e+04 1.44604964e+04 5.15e-06 5.81e-08 2.38e-07 464s
61 1.44583408e+04 1.44604193e+04 4.50e-06 5.34e-08 2.13e-07 474s
62 1.44584618e+04 1.44603407e+04 4.04e-06 4.87e-08 1.92e-07 485s
63 1.44585820e+04 1.44602974e+04 3.57e-06 4.60e-08 1.76e-07 496s
64 1.44587094e+04 1.44602563e+04 3.15e-06 4.36e-08 1.58e-07 507s
65 1.44587853e+04 1.44602326e+04 2.84e-06 4.21e-08 1.48e-07 517s
66 1.44588579e+04 1.44602035e+04 2.47e-06 4.04e-08 1.38e-07 527s
67 1.44589152e+04 1.44601651e+04 3.61e-06 3.81e-08 1.28e-07 545s
68 1.44589858e+04 1.44601346e+04 3.15e-06 3.63e-08 1.17e-07 559s
69 1.44590154e+04 1.44600472e+04 2.99e-06 3.10e-08 1.05e-07 568s
70 1.44590890e+04 1.44599775e+04 2.92e-06 2.68e-08 9.08e-08 578s
71 1.44591323e+04 1.44599396e+04 3.88e-06 2.45e-08 8.26e-08 586s
72 1.44591625e+04 1.44598904e+04 3.58e-06 2.16e-08 7.44e-08 599s
73 1.44592130e+04 1.44598592e+04 3.07e-06 1.97e-08 6.60e-08 611s
74 1.44592226e+04 1.44598493e+04 2.97e-06 1.92e-08 6.40e-08 623s
75 1.44592550e+04 1.44598274e+04 2.64e-06 1.78e-08 5.83e-08 632s
76 1.44592725e+04 1.44598044e+04 2.50e-06 1.64e-08 5.42e-08 644s
77 1.44593024e+04 1.44597770e+04 2.20e-06 1.49e-08 4.81e-08 655s
78 1.44593202e+04 1.44597507e+04 2.02e-06 1.34e-08 4.36e-08 668s
79 1.44593456e+04 1.44597242e+04 1.78e-06 1.18e-08 3.82e-08 679s
80 1.44593541e+04 1.44597129e+04 1.72e-06 1.11e-08 3.62e-08 689s
81 1.44593734e+04 1.44596921e+04 1.53e-06 9.87e-09 3.22e-08 699s
82 1.44593855e+04 1.44596808e+04 1.41e-06 9.17e-09 2.99e-08 711s
83 1.44594011e+04 1.44596717e+04 1.26e-06 8.61e-09 2.74e-08 722s
84 1.44594142e+04 1.44596630e+04 1.12e-06 8.09e-09 2.51e-08 732s
85 1.44594294e+04 1.44596489e+04 9.58e-07 7.26e-09 2.20e-08 744s
86 1.44594383e+04 1.44596344e+04 8.85e-07 6.38e-09 1.96e-08 753s
87 1.44594467e+04 1.44596219e+04 8.08e-07 5.64e-09 1.75e-08 763s
88 1.44594519e+04 1.44596173e+04 8.28e-07 5.37e-09 1.65e-08 774s
89 1.44594595e+04 1.44596091e+04 7.51e-07 1.50e-07 1.50e-08 784s
90 1.44594692e+04 1.44595993e+04 5.51e-06 3.52e-07 1.29e-08 794s
91 1.44594755e+04 1.44595869e+04 4.97e-06 2.90e-07 1.11e-08 804s
92 1.44594791e+04 1.44595842e+04 4.68e-06 2.76e-07 1.05e-08 810s
93 1.44594847e+04 1.44595812e+04 4.18e-06 3.10e-07 9.59e-09 819s
94 1.44594859e+04 1.44595798e+04 4.07e-06 3.00e-07 9.34e-09 825s
95 1.44594907e+04 1.44595746e+04 3.66e-06 2.67e-07 8.36e-09 833s
96 1.44594982e+04 1.44595708e+04 2.97e-06 2.72e-07 7.22e-09 842s
97 1.44594995e+04 1.44595688e+04 2.87e-06 2.47e-07 6.89e-09 848s
98 1.44594995e+04 1.44595688e+04 2.87e-06 2.47e-07 6.89e-09 855s
99 1.44595019e+04 1.44595651e+04 2.66e-06 3.95e-07 6.29e-09 863s
100 1.44595042e+04 1.44595616e+04 2.46e-06 3.52e-07 5.67e-09 871s
101 1.44595047e+04 1.44595605e+04 2.41e-06 3.51e-07 5.50e-09 877s
102 1.44595047e+04 1.44595605e+04 2.41e-06 3.37e-07 5.50e-09 883s
103 1.44595057e+04 1.44595595e+04 2.33e-06 3.74e-07 5.32e-09 890s
104 1.44595075e+04 1.44595581e+04 4.41e-06 3.54e-07 5.00e-09 896s
105 1.44595084e+04 1.44595555e+04 4.25e-06 3.26e-07 4.65e-09 902s
106 1.44595089e+04 1.44595549e+04 4.16e-06 3.38e-07 4.54e-09 910s
107 1.44595117e+04 1.44595536e+04 3.66e-06 3.15e-07 4.13e-09 917s
108 1.44595121e+04 1.44595531e+04 3.59e-06 3.10e-07 4.05e-09 923s
109 1.44595121e+04 1.44595531e+04 3.59e-06 2.98e-07 4.05e-09 929s
110 1.44595126e+04 1.44595526e+04 3.51e-06 2.91e-07 3.95e-09 934s
111 1.44595134e+04 1.44595522e+04 3.38e-06 2.88e-07 3.84e-09 942s
112 1.44595136e+04 1.44595516e+04 3.35e-06 2.75e-07 3.76e-09 948s
113 1.44595136e+04 1.44595515e+04 3.35e-06 2.77e-07 3.75e-09 954s
114 1.44595141e+04 1.44595509e+04 3.17e-06 2.64e-07 3.63e-09 960s
115 1.44595158e+04 1.44595493e+04 2.87e-06 2.88e-07 3.30e-09 968s
116 1.44595161e+04 1.44595489e+04 2.83e-06 2.79e-07 3.24e-09 976s
117 1.44595161e+04 1.44595489e+04 2.83e-06 2.85e-07 3.23e-09 982s
118 1.44595162e+04 1.44595487e+04 2.81e-06 2.80e-07 3.20e-09 989s
119 1.44595166e+04 1.44595486e+04 2.88e-06 2.80e-07 3.16e-09 994s
120 1.44595167e+04 1.44595485e+04 2.86e-06 2.78e-07 3.14e-09 1000s
121 1.44595170e+04 1.44595476e+04 2.73e-06 2.52e-07 3.01e-09 1006s
122 1.44595170e+04 1.44595476e+04 2.73e-06 2.62e-07 3.01e-09 1013s
123 1.44595170e+04 1.44595476e+04 2.73e-06 2.62e-07 3.01e-09 1019s
124 1.44595196e+04 1.44595452e+04 2.22e-06 2.00e-07 2.52e-09 1027s
125 1.44595198e+04 1.44595448e+04 2.33e-06 1.93e-07 2.46e-09 1034s
126 1.44595198e+04 1.44595448e+04 2.33e-06 1.94e-07 2.46e-09 1040s
127 1.44595198e+04 1.44595448e+04 2.33e-06 1.95e-07 2.46e-09 1046s
128 1.44595199e+04 1.44595447e+04 2.34e-06 1.92e-07 2.45e-09 1053s
129 1.44595200e+04 1.44595447e+04 2.32e-06 2.00e-07 2.43e-09 1059s
130 1.44595200e+04 1.44595447e+04 2.32e-06 2.34e-07 2.43e-09 1067s
131 1.44595206e+04 1.44595441e+04 2.21e-06 2.23e-07 2.32e-09 1074s
132 1.44595208e+04 1.44595438e+04 2.17e-06 2.40e-07 2.27e-09 1081s
133 1.44595208e+04 1.44595438e+04 2.17e-06 2.45e-07 2.27e-09 1088s
134 1.44595208e+04 1.44595437e+04 2.17e-06 2.46e-07 2.26e-09 1094s
135 1.44595224e+04 1.44595426e+04 4.83e-06 2.20e-07 2.00e-09 1103s
136 1.44595224e+04 1.44595426e+04 4.83e-06 2.19e-07 2.00e-09 1110s
137 1.44595224e+04 1.44595426e+04 4.83e-06 2.20e-07 2.00e-09 1117s
138 1.44595224e+04 1.44595426e+04 4.83e-06 2.20e-07 2.00e-09 1124s
139 1.44595226e+04 1.44595418e+04 4.70e-06 2.04e-07 1.90e-09 1130s
140 1.44595226e+04 1.44595418e+04 4.70e-06 2.04e-07 1.90e-09 1137s
141 1.44595227e+04 1.44595418e+04 4.68e-06 1.90e-07 1.89e-09 1144s
142 1.44595227e+04 1.44595418e+04 4.68e-06 1.99e-07 1.89e-09 1151s
143 1.44595227e+04 1.44595418e+04 4.68e-06 1.97e-07 1.88e-09 1158s
144 1.44595227e+04 1.44595417e+04 4.67e-06 2.04e-07 1.88e-09 1165s
145 1.44595227e+04 1.44595417e+04 4.67e-06 2.04e-07 1.88e-09 1172s
Barrier performed 145 iterations in 1172.31 seconds (904.85 work units)
Sub-optimal termination - objective 1.44594467e+04
However I don´t get why my calculation returns a wrong result. Is there something I am missing?
I also tried to remove most of the parameters I set and encountered that this solves the problem. But I have no idea why this should change anything...
Thank you very much in advance!
-
正式なコメント
This post is more than two years old. Some information may not be up to date. For current information, please check the Gurobi Documentation or Knowledge Base. If you need more help, please create a new post in the community forum, or try Gurobot, our chatbot interface offering instant, expert-level support.
-
Hi Christian,
it might be possible that you are missing the objective constant.
double objcon = 0.0;
error = GRBGetdblattr(model, "ObjCon", &objcon);
for (i = 0; i < n_vars; i++) { total_obj_by_hand += obj[i] * var_values[i]; }
total_obj_by_hand += objcon;Best regards,
Jaromił0
投稿コメントは受け付けていません。
コメント
2件のコメント